Allah - the Loss of Innocence

First, my deep apologies if, at the end of this posting, the reader gets all angsty and angry.
I just want to be direct.
Gloves' off, braders and sistahs, because I feel that my Malaysia Stability Alert Level has gone from an Orange Zone (where it has been since the March 8, 2008 general elections) into a Light-Red Zone.

I didn't want to specifically comment on what I thought on how Malays and Muslims in Malaysia would feel when the Allah verdict came through on Thursday.
I only commented on the fact that the non-Muslims were celebrating and saying the Malaysia court is independent and brave and free (of course, if the court had ruled the opposite, venom would be spouted by these same guys, who do not seem to care that they are destroying the name of the country every time they attack the courts without any proof).

Instead of saying 'Jesus Christ be praised', many were writing 'Allah be praised'.
So there we have it.
What Muslims in Malaysia (and even in Singapore) had feared all along, that the decision now means:
Allah = God = Jesus Christ = Trinity.

That was why you saw and read some Muslims over in KL kept stressing that Allah means 'one true God'.
They meant to say it is different from the Christian's understanding of a triune God.
Never mind that the Arabs and those in Indonesia may feel differently. In the minds of Malays there in KayEL and beyond, Allah is different from the 'Christian God'.


Now, after three days of reading so many reactions, I could sense that the Malays and Muslims in Malaysia feel deeply aggrieved indeed.
Wow, sooooo many anguished hearts and angry heads.
(Even after we minus off those idiots who always stir in dark waters, like some from Umno, Khir Toyo and Ibrahim Ali).
Well, I thought the Muslims would be angry, but as a semi-outsider, I didn't want to put my case too early for fear of being called an instigator.

All I can say is that the Malay-Muslim position in Malaysia was much weakened in the last five years, by a former prime minister and his stupid advisers (let's not beat around the bush anymore) who thought opening the floodgates of expression and debate were good for the country.
Of course, he lost control, his advisers were too busy making hay, so the country is now in purgatory with too much politicking and debate over race and religion.
To the point that Malay-Muslims now feel the 45 per cent minority groups are pushing at the gates to open up everything and anything for questioning.
Of course, you cannot blame the minorities from pushing! They feel oppressed by 22 years of Mahathirism.
But how I wished the doors to debate and forum had been opened slowly, not thrown open by Badawi and left ajar without controls.


THE SINGAPORE EXPERIENCE
Looking at it from Singapore, where Islam and Malay-Muslims are a mere 15 per cent minority religion and race:
Singapore had never opened the gate to freedom of expression and debate, so that anybody can say anything about religion and think they can hide behind anonymity.
In Temasek, I daresay, the position of Islam and Malay-Muslims are MORE PROTECTED that in Malaysia, where Islam and Malay-Muslims are now "under siege" (according to some Malaysian Muslims).

In Temasek, there had been several cases where young men in internet forums attacked Islam and Muslims in Singapore anonymously. They were tracked down and dragged to court.
- See here, here and here. Reactions among Singapore bloggers.
(Do read these. It will show you, that a Muslim minority like me can just complain to the government about some internet attack against my religion or race, and the government will take action!
(Dey, forget about the schoolgirls kissing in that picture, will you!? There is a long separate story on that 'lesbo' picture alone! The school got into big trouble).
- And a Christian couple who went around giving leaflets on the religion, to Muslims, were jailed.
See here, here and here.
And look what PM Lee Hsien Loong said about aggressive proselytisation (aka dakwah).

No one, my dear, can belittle Islam and Malay-Muslims in Singapore openly and hope to get away with it (Nor can Muslims attack other religions, of course!)
In short, Singapore says there are several issues that we are not ready for open freewheeling debates and discussions yet.
Race and religion are among those.


ADJUSTING POSITIONS
Now that the can has been opened in Malaysia, we shall see whether it contains more worms, or diamonds.
My fervent hope is common sense prevail.
Peace, y'all.

Those Malay-Muslims in PAS and PKR who loved to play politics and hear their own voices - and hoped to gain votes from Chinese and Indians in the Peninsular, and from Sabah and Sarawak Christians - better now decide where they want to go.
We know where Umno stands.

I see top voices from PAS quoted in Utusan - dewan ulama chief Harun Taib, youth chief Nasruddin Hassan and deputy president Nasarudin Mat Isa - standing against the court's decision. Seemingly. Khalid Samad is okay with it.
We shall wait for Brother Anwar, Tok Guru Nik Aziz, PM Najib, DPM Muhyiddin and others who live in the clouds to come down to earth and see how they want to play the game now.
Kit Siang in his blog reported the court's decision, but has not made any personal comments.
Also silent are the MCA and Gerakan heroes.

There are enough unhappy Malay-Muslim voices out there that I have read - go and visit the small blogs along with the big ones, and see the zillion comments below stories and postings - to show that the so-called 'silent majority' among Malay-Muslims are finding their voices.
Because of this one issue alone.

The Malays were quite muted in their reactions on these issues: alleged police abuse, MACC and Teoh Beng Hock, AP and Rafidah, relaxation of Bumi rules in economy. This despite 'Malay' institutions and companies were shamed and named.
Why? Because quietly they acknowledged there were some abuses.

But in an Agama issue like this, there will be political fallout.
And whether the non-Muslim minorities and the politicians like it or not, they now have to adjust their positions accordingly in the next few weeks and months.
To many Malays in Malaysia, the court's decision has meant the Loss of Innocence.


--------------------------------------------------------
PostScript:
A good story to be done is to ask Merdeka Centre, Vox or some other indy research bodies to poll Malays and others on this issue.
Aiyah, don't just poll 1,084 people lah, since many will then say those are not representative views. Poll like 5,000 all across Malaysia.